Proficiency at design is often overlooked as a requirement for a development partner. Regardless of the purpose, or the technology that drives it, the way your website makes your users feel will predict your success.
No detail is above scrutiny within the proper scope and budget.
People are pretty immune to a sales pitch these days. Users know cool when they see it. Count on you’re audience being finicky, and discerning. If you’re not in the demographic you’re trying to appeal to, make sure you choose a developer who knows how to get into the hearts of that group.